Home World Peruvian farmer loses landmark climate case against German energy giant

Peruvian farmer loses landmark climate case against German energy giant

Saul Luciano Lliuya in front of Lake Palcacocha, located at 4,650 meters above sea level at the Huascaran National Park, in Huaraz, northeastern Peru, on May 23, 2022.

Saul Luciano Lliuya in front of Lake Palcacocha, located at 4,650 meters above sea level at the Huascaran National Park, in Huaraz, northeastern Peru, on May 23, 2022. LUKA GONZALES/AFP hide caption

toggle caption

LUKA GONZALES/AFP

LIMA, Peru — A Peruvian farmer and mountain guide has lost a landmark climate change lawsuit against one of Europe’s largest power companies.

Saúl Luciano Lliuya, who lives in a city in the central Ancash region, in the heart of the Andes, sued RWE, one of Europe’s largest emitters of greenhouse gases, over the risk of flooding to his home from a glacial lake swollen by climate change. Although RWE has never operated in Peru, Luciano Lliuya argued the company’s emissions contributed to the melting glaciers threatening his city.

But a court in Hamm, in northwestern Germany, ruled that the probability of the lake bursting its banks and devastating his home and the homes of some 50,000 other people in the area was too small for RWE to be held liable. It also barred him from appealing the verdict.

Sponsor Message

The ruling brings to an end a decade-long lawsuit in which Luciano Lliuya, supported by environmental group Germanwatch, had sought roughly $18,000 from RWE to pay for 0.5% of the cost of building a dyke to protect his home and the homes of his neighbors – the percentage equal to the proportion of RWA’s total historic carbon emissions according to Germanwatch.

The company is now moving quickly into renewable energy and vows to become carbon neutral by 2040. But its power plants have been running on coal for more than a century.

Germanwatch warned that Lake Palcacocha had swollen to more than 30 times its historic volume and could overflow catastrophically in the event of an avalanche.

Ultimately, the court ruled that the probability of that happening was just over 1% in the next 30 years, below the threshold under German law for RWE to be found liable.

The German energy giant had argued that the issue of climate change should be resolved by governments and not in a court. In a statement after the verdict on Wednesday, RWE said a win against them would have had “unforeseeable consequences for Germany as an industrial location, because ultimately claims could be asserted against any German company anywhere in the world for damage caused by climate change.”

Sponsor Message

This is just one of a wave of climate litigation cases against big industry and governments in recent years. Germanwatch is still claiming a win. It says that the court ruled on the specific risk of Lake Palcacocha bursting its banks. But, by allowing the case to proceed through the German court system for a decade, had accepted the broader principle that climate change plaintiffs from around the world can use German property laws to sue German companies over their carbon emissions.

Petra Minnerop, an expert in international climate law at the United Kingdom’s Durham University, who was not involved in the case, broadly backed Germanwatch’s interpretation. “It was only a factual question, not a legal one,” she told NPR, meaning that the door remained open for similar litigation in Germany.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

U.S. officials on rare visit to controversial Gaza aid distribution site

This handout photo from US Embassy Jerusalem shows White House special envoy Steve Witkoff, center, visiting a food distribution site run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a U.S.-backed organization approved by Israel, in the Gaza Strip Friday, Aug. 1, 2025. David Azaguri/US Embassy Jerusalem via AP hide caption toggle caption David Azaguri/US Embassy Jerusalem via

France, U.K., others plan to recognize a Palestinian state. What does that change?

A flag with a watermelon, a symbol of Palestinian identity, is waved during the Red Line for Gaza protest in Paris on July 8. Henrique Campos/AFP via Getty Images hide caption toggle caption Henrique Campos/AFP via Getty Images France and the United Kingdom are among the latest countries preparing to formally recognize a state of

More than 1,000 rabbis and Jewish leaders denounce starvation in Gaza

People attend an interfaith service on October 29, 2018 at Adas Israel Congregation in Washington, D.C. Alex Wong/Getty Images/Getty Images North America hide caption toggle caption Alex Wong/Getty Images/Getty Images North America More than 1,000 rabbis and other Jewish leaders from around the globe, including in Israel and the U.S., have signed a public letter

Ukraine approves law restoring independence of anti-graft watchdogs following backlash

Demonstrators protest against the bill proposed by President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Kyiv, Ukraine, Thursday. Efrem Lukatsky/AP hide caption toggle caption Efrem Lukatsky/AP KYIV, Ukraine — After a public outcry and pressure from the European Union, a new law is now in force in Ukraine restoring the independence of state agencies investigating corruption. World Activists in

Scientists in South Africa are making rhino horns radioactive to fight poaching

A sedated rhino is being prepared before a hole is drilled into its horn and isotopes carefully inserted, at a rhino orphanage in Mokopane, South Africa, Thursday, July 31, 2025. Alfonso Nqunjana/AP hide caption toggle caption Alfonso Nqunjana/AP MOKOPANE, South Africa (AP) — A South African university launched an anti-poaching campaign Thursday to inject the